Thursday, September 4, 2008

Mandatory Head Coverings?

I have taken quite a long break from blogging. One reason is astounding busyness. The other reason has more to do with feeling reflective as of late: mulling, examining and processing instead of proclaiming and soap-boxing. :) Anyway, I'm back and returning to the subject of head coverings for women and hair length for men.


My last post on head coverings highlighted the varying customs among religions and cultures in the ancient world on the subject. Read here for a refresher.

Now that we know each culture (and subculture for that matter) had varying policies and motives when it came to head coverings, we can see how all these ideas collided in the church, once all kinds of people began converting to Christianity. Paul's letter to the Corinthians reveals quite a number of divisive disputes infecting the church there.

We must remember, as nearly all historical records confirm, that the early church was largely made up of women and slaves. Since most women married in all three cultures, we know that many Christian women were in "mixed" marriages with unbelievers. Since women could be divorced, beaten into submission, or ostracized from their families without legal recourse (especially in a Greek city, like Corinth), it was imperative to protect these women. This is what I believe is driving Paul's passage on head coverings. We find the same sort of concern from Peter who encourages wives to win over their husbands through a loving example, "without a word." To our modern ears, it sounds as if Peter thinks women should be seen and not heard, that they are not to usurp a man's place by vocalizing the gospel to men, even their own husbands. But the reality is that these women's lives were at stake. If they vocalized their faith to their unbelieving husbands, they would likely face abandonment, abuse, public humiliation, destitution, the taking away of their children and even death. Peter and Paul knew full well what the consequences of women preaching the gospel to their unbelieving husbands could bring. Veiling/unveiling could bring equally dire consequences to women, especially if they were married to unbelievers.

The fact of the precarious fate of women in the ancient world alone should signal to modern readers to proceed with caution before handing out head coverings for women and measuring the length of hair on men.

But as I pointed out before, Paul's arguments go BEYOND cultural factors, but that doesn't mean culture had nothing to do with it. So do not think I am dismissing this passage based on culture alone. I am just asking that readers admit that women of faith found themselves in a dangerous and complicated time that we spoiled American Christians can barely comprehend.

The next post will focus on the abundance of textual problems in 1 Corinthians 11:1-16: mainly translation options and and the inconsistent interpretations of this passage that are out of line with other scriptures.

9 comments:

Carlos said...

Welcome back Tia,

Your line about doing more reflecting and thinking lately struck a chord with me and while reading a few choices blogs, I'm restraining myself to not soap box with my comments...but I will say this, I wish I had my 60s hair back :-)

Rachel said...

Have you read Gilbert Bilezikian on this issue? 'Beyong sex Roles', he says that 'to oppose false teachers, Paul cites in chapter 11: 6-10 their own legalistic arguments while reasserting his teaching ...he cites disapprovingly the argument relative to veils, hair and angels that the Judaizers propounded...Paul quotes in this section his opponents' arguments to turn them upside-down on their heads and, by doing so, to oppose them more convincingly...he invalidates their argument... [for head-coverings]with the startling declaration that a woman's hair is her pride and that "her hair has been given to her instead of a veil." Since a women's hair makes the veil redundant, it follows that women may lead in worship and proclaim the Word of God without having to wear the mark of subordination that the false teachers were trying to impose on them as a slight."

Thank you for your work on these ideas. I have discovered you due to a recommendation - your posting on 1 Tim 2 11-15. I found this very useful and wish I had had access to it earlier in 07 when I needed it.

God bless you
Rachel at Re vis.e Re form.
The Yellow Wallpaper made a big impression on me when I read it at uni. I see you list it in your profile.

I think we probably have a fair amount in common. You struck a chord with me too about your concern over the soap box - I have my more reflective times too and love them but I'm not sure if God is actually asking me to step down from my soap-box - I think that I can serve a purpose by remaining upon it. X

Carlos said...

Rachel, I'm glad someone else is now quoting Bilzekian; this latest post from Tia has been pretty much dormant lately which makes me wonder if Tia is Ok....

Anonymous said...

Tia,
I liked your post. How are you feeling? Blesssings and grace -Rachel

Carlos said...

Tia, Congrats and all the best...

God bless...

Carlos

Anonymous said...

SEO焼酎インプラントキャッシング 比較レンタルサーバー美容整形不動産株式年金サプリメントビジネスマナー占い海外挙式アクセスカウンターオークションエステサイト売買バイク買取家庭教師自動車保険

Randi Jo :) said...

i'm in a discussion about head coverings with a friend..... and want to hear the rest of what you have to say! :) bring it! :)

Anonymous said...

Здравствуйте,

Надежная и проверенная [url=http://popplers.ru/]партнерка[/url] [b]Popplers.ru[/b] предлагает Вам сотрудничество на выгодных условиях. Мы покупаем ваш ру трафик по выгодным ценам. Владельцам сайтов, вебмагазинов и веб мастерам мы предоставляем выгодные условия, отзывчивую поддержку и проффесиональный подход в непростом бизнесе рунета.
отличная возможность надежно заработать, выгодная рефферальная программа, направьте ваш ру трафик в нужное русло, в русло прибыли которое принесет вам [url=http://popplers.ru/]Партнерская программа[/url] [b]Popplers.ru[/b] . Вывод средств в WebMoney или PayPal, возможность срочных выплат в любой день недели, личный подход к каждому партнеру.

Покупаем ру трафик по следующим ценам за 1k:

DoorWays - 6у.е.
Popunder - 5у.е.
CJ - 5 у.е.
Clickunder - 4 у.е.

Ждем Вас в наших рядах!

ICQ: 498994074

Anonymous said...

たしかに無料で出会える無料出会い(人気無料出会いのイイコイ、出会い率が高いガールズコム、出会いの老舗モバコイなど)でも出会うのは難しい、どうせ会うならサクラのいない出会い系ワクワクメールや老舗出会い系のハッピーメール、194964のイクヨクルヨ、出会いMAXのPCMAXなんかの出会い系がいいよ。
携帯電話で話したりできるライブチャットツーショットも、たまに会えたりするからオススメですよ。
占いなんかもあるし、占星術タロット占いはないけど、楽しいし、ポイント購入したりお金がかかるけど、万が一お金がなくなって、お金を借りたいなら、クレジットカードのショッピング枠を現金化すればいいと思う。
あと、前から欲しかったカラコンをカラコン通販で買っちゃった。